Richer by the Day
Ongoing ramblings about personal finance, and all related topics. If it has to do with money, it will be covered here.

Filed under Lending Club, P2P Lending, Saving

Many convenience stores use drop safes to prevent burglaries. A drop safe allows money to easily be deposited, but not easily withdrawn. A cashier might deposit a set amount of cash into the drop safe once the register hits a certain limit. Doing so keeps the unprotected amount (in the register) small while allowing the protected amount (in the drop safe) to grow. Applying the concept of a drop safe to your financial plan can help you to save.

The idea of a drop safe is useful, but as we rarely want our savings to be sitting in cash, a “virtual” drop safe is more appropriate. Just like it’s real world counterpart, we want it to be easy to put money into and hard to get it out of. As in the convenience store case, the reason to use a drop safe is to protect your money from being stolen. In the case of your personal finances, you are trying to protect your money from yourself, and your desire to spend. Some examples of virtual drop safe accounts include IRAs and 401(k)s, CDs, or structured investments like P2P loans. Let’s look at one of those examples, the CD, to see how it would work.

A CD works like a drop safe because it’s easy to put money in, but you can’t get your money back out until some future date. The returns on that investment tend to be better than a traditional savings account as a result of this loss of liquidity. Even in the case of CDs though, you can pay a penalty if you really need to get the money back out. Similar provisions tend to exist in retirement accounts as well.

If you are going to cave in and break into your virtual drop safe by paying a penalty, save yourself the trouble and expense and don’t bother trying to save in this way. If you are disciplined, then using a virtual drop safe may not be necessary at all. Most of us fall somewhere in between those two cases. For us, the hurdles of getting money out of a virtual drop safe account may be all the incentive we need to keep that money in there and allow it to really grow.

Even a minor inconvenience may be sufficient to dissuade taking money out. I use a direct bank account (HSBC Direct) because it offers a better rate than CDs, while still being fairly liquid. The fact that it takes a few days to transfer money out of the account is the deterrent that helps me to save. Even though it’s not much of a hassle to get money out, the minor inconvenience is enough that I rarely withdraw from that account. For me, direct banking offers the perfect balance of deterrent, liquidity, and return on investment that I’m looking for.

Another great virtual drop safe, that I mentioned above, is a P2P loan portfolio. Using my Lending Club account, I get a great return on my money, while only allowing myself access to a small fraction of it each month. Loans on Lending Club are repaid monthly and have a term of 36 months. So I basically can only access 1/36th of the money that I have invested there at a time. Most months I just roll the payments I receive into new loans so that the interest I earn can compound. If you are interested in opening an account with Lending Club, use this referral link.

Whichever method of virtual drop safe you implement, the goal is the same: place a barrier between your income and your desire to spend. Saving not only causes you to spend less, it also allows your money to work for you by earning interest. Passive income such as this is really helpful in not only reaching your financial goals, but also allowing you to have enough free time to enjoy those goals once they are achieved.


If you enjoyed this post, subscribe to my feed via RSS or email.

You can support Richer by the Day by visiting our advertisers and sponsors. A thumbs up from any StumbleUpon users would also be greatly appreciated.


Related Posts

Buying Generic
Tax Credit 2008 Weekend Roundup
Thirsty for Change
Envelope Budgeting in the Modern World
Researching Potential Houses

3 Responses to “Using a Virtual Drop Safe to Help You Save”

  1. Mark @ TheLocoMono Says:

    I am sorry, did I read that right? Lending Club is like a virtual drop safe? Even if the borrower defaults?

    The drop safes used by banks only serves as a holding tank. It would not give you interest from the time you dropped your deposit in the safe to the time it is deposited in your account.

    I have to admit, I agree with you on the virtues of a drop safe (easy to put in, harder to take out) but I am leery about P2P being considered a virtual drop safe.

  2. Mike Says:

    Mark,
    I understand your concern and wasn’t trying to imply that any one P2P loan is a safe investment. Clearly, default is always a possibility. I was talking about a portfolio of P2P loans, which can greatly reduce the risk. The P2P lending sites all tend to advocate lending small amounts to as many people as possible. Overall return will be reduced by those loans that do default, but in the aggregate, that should only have a minor impact on overall performance if you make a sufficiently large number of loans. Promotions and bonuses from the P2P sites serve as further protection against default risk.

    The whole idea of a virtual drop safe is to get your money locked away where it can grow in value. If you’re only comfortable with guaranteed returns, that’s a fine method to implement. Adding risk will, of course, allow for the possibility of greater returns. For me, the returns of P2P loans are significantly high enough that I am confident that my money will grow, even with the occasional default. I tend to significantly overestimate the likelihood of default, and still like my odds.

Trackbacks

  1. Saving Money Despite Living Paycheck to Paycheck

Leave a Reply




Subscribe to Richer by the Day

  

 Subscribe via RSS

  

 Subscribe via Email

  Please follow me on Twitter!

  Add to Technorati Favorites