In the past, I have advocated building a cash emergency fund. By “cash” I mean a liquid form of money which could be actual currency, but preferably would be savings in a high yield direct bank account. There has been some insightful commentary recently that has caused me to re-evaluate my position and add some justification to it. Of the many posts on the subject, two were my inspiration for this post. In the first one, Mike from four pillars discussed why a HELOC can be used instead of an emergency fund. In the second one, the money gardener explains why he doesn’t need an emergency fund.
In most cases, an emergency fund is really just a method to avoid debt. If a true emergency arose, which exhausted our cash reserves, most of us would just use credit cards, a home equity loan, or a P2P loan. All of those methods are nearly as liquid as cash and easily obtained, with a cost association in the form of interest.
Continue >>






